Executive Coaching Case Studies
Below are three case studies. All three clients have kindly given their permission to include them here.
Some background details have been changed to preserve their anonymity.
Case Study #1: Rapid Turnaround
Tom was the Technical Director of a £5m engineering firm in Scotland. An experienced, thoughtful man in his late 40s, he’d joined the business three years earlier to help the MD win more sales in four ways.
First, by raising on-time product delivery as too many custom products were arriving later than promised. Second, by delivering the products faster. Third, by responding quicker to customers’ requests for quotes. Fourth, by introducing new products.
Tom hired four new engineers and invested in new machines. But after three years, results were bad. The most important metric – on-time product delivery – had worsened. There’d been no invention. Product lead times had lengthened and were now behind the industry average. And customers were receiving their quotes even slower than before.
Eventually the MD had had enough. He told Tom that unless he achieved these three goals within seven months without incurring extra costs he’d be fired:
- Raise on-time delivery from 40% to 80%.
- Cut lead times from 11 weeks to 9 weeks.
- Raise the % of customer quotes answered within 5 days from 42% to 60%.
In working with me, Tom’s first challenge was to accept his poor record. This was hard. He prided himself on his intellect and technical know-how. He recognised that his suppressed feelings of anger and humiliation had made him defensive with his senior colleagues. And he realised that his habit of convincing himself that “the criticism I’m getting is unfair” was distracting him from his key tasks.
He let go of his old “I’m right, they’re wrong” attitude. He shifted from anger to determination. Then he focused on what he needed to do and achieved the results you see in the graphs below.
As you can see, Tom transformed his department’s results on every metric, surpassing his goals:
- On-time delivery rose from 40% to 93%.
- Lead-times were slashed from 11 to 7 weeks.
- The % of quotes answered within 5 days lifted from 42% to 63%.
The MD had dreamt of a turnaround, but doubted he’d see it. He told Tom, “This is an astounding success.” He was right. It was. The triple turnaround boosted sales, adding £90,000 extra margin in seven months (8 times the cost of the coaching).
Case Study #2: From Manager to Leader
Jack ran a manufacturing plant with 250 employees. Everyone knew he had talent. He got things done and always hit his targets. The trouble is, he didn’t connect with people.
A 360° survey showed that others saw him as uninspiring, unapproachable, uncaring and uninterested in their welfare. His peers didn’t trust him – they felt he was only interested in one person: himself. He was good, but the company knew his self-centredness and lack of empathy would cause his best people to rebel or leave the business. So they asked me to help. Jack was shocked when he saw the 360° survey results. He told me, “It was horrible. Humiliating. I couldn’t sleep properly for three days.”
He worked with me for thirteen months. Jack unearthed an intense fear of failure based on a deeper belief that he “wasn’t good enough”, which made him self-centred and over-controlling. He also believed that people weren’t interested in talking to him unless he had a work-related reason for approaching them. So he avoided talking to people in his workforce he didn’t know well, which was most of them. But this meant he wasn’t getting the engagement he wanted.
Gradually, as we worked together, his attitude and behaviour changed. His old negative beliefs melted and he began practising new habits. Then we repeated the 360° survey. There was a turnaround in the way people viewed him, as you see in the graph below.
Now they saw him as visible, inspiring, better at handling conflict, approachable and caring. His peers saw him differently too – now they trusted him. And he was still great at getting results – his latest initiative added £1.5 million to profits, bringing him global recognition within the company.
Two years after the coaching he was promoted to Operations Director.
Case Study #3: Transformation
Diego was VP Finance for the European region of an international software company. Intellectually brilliant, driven and superbly qualified, he was also a talented athlete who excelled at tennis. He was ethical, energetic, forceful and focused. A real high-achiever.
But he wasn’t good at leading people. Quite the opposite in fact.
Many colleagues described him as abrasive, moody and irritable. Others saw him as hostile, dictatorial at times and disrespectful towards others’ views or explanations. They felt his interpersonal sensitivity and skill didn’t match his intellect, financial nous and energy. The board recognised Diego’s ability. But as talented as he was, they wouldn’t promote him if he couldn’t change his attitude and behaviour. Even worse, they felt he was in danger of derailing.
We worked together for 12 months. Before long he had two big insights.
First, that he believed he had to micromanage his staff to avoid any risk of failure. For Diego, failure wasn’t an option. It would be too humiliating. Anything would be better than that.
Second, that he’d seen the idea of spending time connecting with people outside his team as time poorly spent. Why? He told himself they weren’t significant enough to justify time away from his family. But that wasn’t the real reason. He thought they weren’t interested in him – that they’d ignore him if he started non-financial conversations. So he avoided engaging with people.
Having surfaced and dissolved these beliefs, Diego worked hard on changing his behavioural habits under pressure. When we compared his mental performance state and behavioural skill before and after the coaching we found this:
As the graph shows, there was a huge shift pre- and post-coaching. Now colleagues and staff saw him differently. His two biggest critics said: “It’s such a big shift that it’s surprised me” and “It’s a transformation”. A board member told Diego, “This is a phenomenal turnaround.”
Soon afterwards, Diego suggested reconsidering an old idea for boosting margins they’d previously considered “too difficult”. Diego’s new leadership skill and persistence shattered the old status quo, convincing his peers and seniors to act. His intervention added $13 million to profits (565 times the cost of the coaching). Two years later they promoted him to global vice-president.